Skip to main content

Australia-Myanmar Constitutional Workshop

On 26-27 November 2014, the Australia-Myanmar Constitutional Democracy Workshop was held at Sedona Hotel in Yangon. Building on the constitutional law workshop held in 2013, this workshop had a particular focus on constitutional principles and institutions. The workshop was hosted by the University of New South Wales, and also included academics from NUS, ANU, Canada and Germany. The workshop was attended by a range of lawyers, legal professionals and NGOs in Yangon. 

I contributed to a panel on the separation of powers, and focused specifically on states of emergency. The constitutional power of the executive to declare a state of emergency continues to present a challenge to the rule of law around the world. For example, in 2014, states of emergency were declared by the governments in Liberia, Sierra Leone and Nigeria respectively, in response to the serious health risk presented by the Ebola virus. Other states of emergency are more controversial and have been declared in response to internal unrest. For example, in August 2014, the Governor of Missouri (United States) declared a state of emergency in the city of Ferguson, after the shooting of an unarmed black teenager by the police led to peaceful protests that at times resulting in vandalism. 

I emphasised that while each emergency may be unique to the local context, they raise similar questions about the limits on this power; the definition of an emergency; and the role of the military. In Myanmar, over the past two years, we have already seen at least nine separate orders issued under section 144 of the Criminal Procedure Code by the General Administration Department that have imposed restrictions on freedom of movement and association. I suggested that this should raise issues of concern because section 144 is supposed to be a judicial power, not an executive power; the General Administration Department is under the Minister of Home Affairs, who is selected by the Commander-in-Chief; and an order under section 144 seems to be a precondition to a constitutional state of emergency. I concluded by suggesting that while the constitutional powers to declare a state of emergency are still of serious concern, that the more immediate issue is the exercise of similar powers under section 144.





Popular posts from this blog

The impact of Covid-19 on research

Covid-19 is currently disrupting academic publishing in a number of ways. 
There are disruptions to the global supply chain for the manufacture and distribution of printed journals. The following publishers have halted journal printing until further notice: Cambridge University Press (from 25 March 2020) Taylor & Francis (from 10 April)
Some journal editors or editing boards have suspended or delayed the review or publication process for academic journals. 
On the other hand, some publishers are providing open access content for a limited period of time. See the following links from the UNSW library and the ANU library, or select publishers websites such as OUP.  The University of California Press has opened free access to all its journals until the end of June 2020
Hart Publishing is currently offering free access for libraries to its online platform, Bloomsbury Collections, until the end of May. To enable access for your institution, email Hart atOnlineSalesUK@bloomsbury.com

The Austral…

Access to Justice and Administrative Law in Myanmar

Administrative law is an important part of access to justice because it can operate as a check and balance on government decision-making, and provide an avenue for individuals to seek review of government decisions.

In a report sponsored by USAID and TetraTech for their 'Promoting the Rule of Law in Myanmar' program, I emphasise the importance of administrative law in Myanmar in promoting good governance, accountability and checks on executive power. 
The main avenue for judicial review of administrative action in Myanmar is the constitutional writs under the 2008 Constitution. Since 2011, a large number of applications for the constitutional writs have been brought to the Supreme Court. The Writ Procedure Law 2014 was introduced to clarify the Supreme Court procedure for handling writ cases. The constitutional writs are a new area of law and support needs to be provided to a range of legal actors in order to take hold of the potential opportunity this provides. 
Efforts must als…

Professional Legal Education in Commercial and Corporate Law in Myanmar

Dr Melissa Crouch and Associate Professor Lisa Toohey of UNSW Law Faculty are undertaking a Professional Legal Education Project in Commercial and Corporate law in Myanmar (2016-2017), funded by the Asian Development Bank. Melissa Crouch is the Team leader and Legal Education and Myanmar Law expert. Lisa Toohey is the Legal Education and Commercial Law expert on the project. Emma Dunlop is the Legal Researcher and Project administrator.

The focus of the project is on improving legal education and skills integral to the transactional practice and adjudication of commercial law, at this critical time in Myanmar's transition to democracy. The project includes developing a training program for the practical legal training needs of private lawyers, government lawyers, prosecutors and judges in commercial and financial law. 


In 2016, the first stage of the project has included meetings and focus group discussions with most of the major law firms - foreign and local - in Yangon. It has als…